Sample report · United States

US dairy, 3 000 cows, RNG

A sample Extended Report for a modelled project. Your report has the same structure (the Standard Report has fewer sections) and uses your own data.

Business situation

A Wisconsin dairy with 3,000 cows and 1,500 young cattle compares on-site energy with renewable natural gas. The report tests the project before relying on environmental credits.

Operating assumptions

  • Dairy cows: 3,000 · Housed all year
  • Young / beef cattle: 1,500 · Housed all year
  • Electricity: 2,500,000 kWh/yr · Electricity price on your bill (if known): —
  • All year: hot water, steam, process · Heat needed per year (if known): 800,000 kWh/yr
  • Land available for spreading digestate: 2,500 ha · Distance to the gas grid (for biomethane): 3 km
  • Existing lagoon / store that could be covered: 40,000 m³
  • Grid connection? Yes

What to verify

Verify actual collection, winter heating, utility interconnection and methane losses. Obtain pathway eligibility, credit ownership and net-of-fees offtake terms separately.

Weak economics

Under current conditions the investment won't pay back in a reasonable time. Below is what could change that.

  • Simple payback > 25.0 yrs; base NPV -US$4.2M (well below zero at the country discount rate).
  • Even the optimistic case has a negative NPV (-US$2.7M).

Main reason — ≈ 82 % of the heat has no user, so half of the plant's energy earns nothing.

What would change the verdict
  • → NPV = 0 with ≈ 65 % lower CAPEX (or an equivalent grant).
  • → NPV = 0 with ≈ 105 % higher energy prices.
  • → Check whether the project qualifies for “RFS D3 + California LCFS (manure RNG)”: if it does, this project turns profitable (NPV above zero). Confirm eligibility with the scheme operator before paying for a feasibility study.

Subsidies and tariffs excluded from the verdict. Preliminary screening, not an engineering design.

How firm is this answer?

A clear no under these conditions: even the optimistic case does not pay back. Don't spend money on a feasibility study unless one of the changes above happens.

NPV: conservative -US$7.2M · base -US$4.2M · optimistic -US$2.7M

The conservative case stacks every adverse assumption at once: a stress test, not the likely outcome. In 160 likely combinations the NPV was positive in < 1 % of cases.

These are screening assumptions, not independently validated accuracy limits. Confirm BMP, supplier scope, grid connection and offtake terms before an investment decision.

Key figures

Ranges: conservative — base — optimistic. We don't show fake precision.

Economics

Preliminary investment
US$4.8M – US$6.4M
Payback
22.8 yr – no payback
base: > 25 yr · no subsidies
NPV (base)
-US$4.2M
range: -US$7.2M … -US$2.7M
Chosen route
CHP (power + heat)
Confidence: Medium

1 EUR = 1.1193 USD · ECB · 2026-11-09

Feedstock and energy

Feedstock potential
74,000 t/yr
energy ≈ 197 kWh CH₄/t
Biogas
2M – 3M Nm³/yr
≈ 335 Nm³/h (base)
Net energy
4,000 – 5,800 MWh/yr
useful heat: 480 – 760 MWh · ≈ 85 % of your electricity use
Candidate capacity
760 kWe
medium (0.25–1 MW)

How far you can rely on these numbers

Medium · 62/100
  • Backed by your data and our sources62
  • You can still add+28
  • Needs a feasibility study (lab, quotes, contracts)10

62/100: how much of what a screening can know about this project rests on your data and current sources. A missing input costs points in proportion to how far it could still move your result.

What you can add

  • Biggest gainLaboratory DM, VS and BMP results for every feedstock streamLarge effectSend a sample to a laboratory: dry matter and VS take a few days, BMP several weeks+15
  • Route-specific CAPEX lacks independent local validation — obtain comparable supplier quotations+8
  • Electricity price on your bill (if known) (USD/kWh)Large effectTotal of one bill divided by the kWh on it+5

With all of it: up to 90/100

High requires verified laboratory and project documents, so a screening stops at 90/100.

Model warnings
  • CHP performance uses a 60 Hz biogas full-load catalogue reference (04/2025), interpolated between ratings; part-load and ambient derating require supplier confirmation.
Compared with the market
Our estimate: ≈ 7,000 USD/kW at ≈ 760 kW
  • 3,806–8,395 USD/kW — Flexible plant, Germany · within rangeDBFZ / Fraunhofer IEE for BMWK (February 2024): €7,521 per kW rated (≈ €3,400 per kW installed) capacity · 2023 · Official study
  • 3,134–7,835 USD/kW — Agricultural plants, Poland · within rangePolish trade press 2023–2024 (PLN 7–20 m for 500 kW; PLN 12–16 m for 1 MW); IOŚ-PIB: ≈ PLN 30 m for 1 MW · 2023–2024 · Trade press
  • 3,358–5,037 USD/kW — Biogas plants, Ukraine · above rangeSupplier estimate (Zorg Biogas, ≈ €3,500/kW at 1 MW — primary source not found); Ecodevelop 333 kW ≈ €1.5 m (older project) · ≈2013–2020 · Supplier estimate

Market figures are mostly trade press and supplier estimates, not audited budgets. Real prices come from 3–5 supplier quotes.

Country conditions
  • Low gas prices make biogas without credits unattractive; transport-fuel credits, not electricity savings, decide most US projects.

Action plan: what would make it stronger

Changes tested on this project with the same model. Break-even values show how far each must go; the scenario assumptions are LOW-confidence judgements to replace with offers.

What separates this project from “Possible with conditions”
  • The base-case NPV is negative (-US$4.2M).
  • Payback in the base case is > 25 yr; it needs to be 10 yr or less.
ChangeVerdictNPV (base)Δ NPVBreak-even
Sell the spare heat
A year-round heat buyer (drying, process heat, greenhouse or district heating) for ≈ 2,300 MWh a year, valued at ≈ US$0.0277 per kWh.
Weak economics-US$3.6M+US$670Kheat ≥ US$0.143 per kWh
Take in food waste
≈ 16,000 t a year of source-separated food waste from ≈ 15 km away, with a gate fee of US$6.7 per tonne.
Weak economics-US$9.7M-US$5.5Mgate fee ≥ US$64.9 per tonne
Pool manure with neighbours
100 % more manure from neighbouring farms, trucked ≈ 5 km, into one shared plant.
Weak economics-US$13M-US$9.1M—
Order of action
  1. 1Find a heat buyer for ≈ 2,300 MWh a year (heat ≥ US$0.143 per kWh).
  2. 2Ask 3–5 suppliers for quotes: the project breaks even up to an investment of US$1.9M. →
Scenario assumptions
  • Co-substrate share of the organic matter (VS) after it is added: 30 % · ASSUMPTION · LOW · 2026-11-02 · Judgement: usual co-digestion share at manure plants; the model applies pasteurisation, rejects and inhibition checks to the new mix.
  • Haul distance of the co-substrate: 15 km · ASSUMPTION · LOW · 2026-11-02 · Judgement: food processors within a regional collection radius.
  • Gate fee received for source-separated food waste: US$6.72/t · ASSUMPTION · LOW · 2026-11-02 · Judgement, deliberately low. WRAP UK Gate Fees Report 2025/26 (3 July 2026): AD gate fees fell from 2024/25 and several councils paid £0 or less. The paid report gives the gate fee at which the scenario breaks even.
  • Haul distance of the neighbours' feedstock: 5 km · ASSUMPTION · LOW · 2026-11-02 · Judgement: neighbouring farms within a few kilometres; slurry hauled much further rarely pays (see the maximum distance per stream).

What to verify first

Inputs ranked by what exact knowledge is worth before you decide (expected value of perfect information). Each range is tested on its own; inputs you already supplied are not listed.

CheckNPV across the plausible rangeWorth knowing
Get supplier quotes for the plant-US$6.2M … -US$2.3M—
Check your electricity bill (energy price)-US$4.7M … -US$3.8M—
Check how your bill splits energy and capacity charges-US$4.6M … -US$3.8M—
Weigh or meter the manure actually collected-US$4.7M … -US$4M—
Lab test of the methane yield (BMP)-US$4.7M … -US$4.2M—
Check the fertiliser value of the digestate-US$4.4M … -US$4M—
How to check: Get supplier quotes for the plant
  1. Send the same request to at least three suppliers.
  2. Compare like for like: scope, exclusions, guaranteed gas output, own power use, availability and the O&M price.
Request to send
Request for quotation: turnkey biogas plant
Site: United States.
Feedstock (screening values, to be confirmed):
- dairy cattle slurry: 62,000 t/year, DM ≈ 12.8 %
- beef / young cattle slurry: 13,000 t/year, DM ≈ 7.5 %
Design basis from the screening: raw biogas ≈ 330 Nm³/h at ≈ 55 % CH₄; digester working volume ≈ 7,100 m³; combined heat and power ≈ 760 kWe; new digestate storage ≈ 0 m³.
Please quote turnkey: feeding, digester(s), gas system with flare and desulphurisation, the gas-use equipment above, electrical and I&C, civil works, engineering and commissioning. List exclusions (grid connection, permits, land, digestate storage if separate). State the guaranteed gas output, own power and heat use, availability and the price of a full O&M contract.

Then enter it in: Step 3, “Optional: contracts and financing”: supplier quote and its technology

How to check: Check your electricity bill (energy price)
  1. Take the last 12 electricity invoices.
  2. Split each into the energy part (per kWh) and capacity, network and fixed charges; own generation saves mainly the energy part.

Then enter it in: Energy step: electricity price per kWh (energy part, excl. VAT)

How to check: Check how your bill splits energy and capacity charges
  1. Take the last 12 electricity invoices.
  2. Split each into the energy part (per kWh) and capacity, network and fixed charges; own generation saves mainly the energy part.

Then enter it in: Energy step: electricity price per kWh (energy part, excl. VAT)

How to check: Weigh or meter the manure actually collected
  1. Count animals by group and housing period for the last 12 months.
  2. Measure slurry pit levels over 30 days (or weigh loads) and take three DM samples.

Then enter it in: Feedstock step: quantity and DM of each stream

How to check: Lab test of the methane yield (BMP)
  1. Take 3–5 subsamples of each stream over 2–4 weeks, mix them, keep them at 4 °C and deliver within 24 h.
  2. Order dry matter (DM), volatile solids (VS) and a methane potential test (BMP, VDI 4630) with the cellulose control reported.
  3. A valid test reports cellulose at 340–395 NL CH₄/kg VS; ask for a repeat otherwise.
Request to send
Request for quotation: biogas potential analysis
Site: United States.
Feedstock (screening values, to be confirmed):
- dairy cattle slurry: 62,000 t/year, DM ≈ 12.8 %
- beef / young cattle slurry: 13,000 t/year, DM ≈ 7.5 %
Design basis from the screening: raw biogas ≈ 330 Nm³/h at ≈ 55 % CH₄; digester working volume ≈ 7,100 m³; combined heat and power ≈ 760 kWe; new digestate storage ≈ 0 m³.
Per sample please quote: dry matter (DM, % of fresh mass), volatile solids (VS, % of DM) and biochemical methane potential (BMP, NL CH₄ per kg VS) to VDI 4630, with the cellulose control result and the test duration. Please state price, turnaround time and sampling and shipping instructions.

Then enter it in: Feedstock step: DM, VS and BMP on each stream

How to check: Check the fertiliser value of the digestate
  1. Ask neighbouring farms what they would pay per tonne of digestate, delivered and spread.
  2. Check the land available for spreading against the nitrogen limit.

Then enter it in: Site step: land available for digestate

Break-even prices

Each value on its own brings the base-case NPV to zero; everything else stays as calculated.

Electricity value at NPV = 0
US$0.138/kWh
now US$0.0659/kWh
Highest installed cost at NPV = 0
US$1.9M
now US$5.3M
Feedstock price headroom
US$5.06/t
needs US$5.06 per tonne less cost, or a gate fee, on every input

Probability range (Monte Carlo)

160 draws of the scenario quantities (yield, dry matter, CAPEX, prices, heat use, operating hours…). Energy and biomethane prices move together, the rest independently. Not a forecast: it shows how often the project stays positive when the uncertainties do not all go wrong at once.

NPV P10 (1 in 10 worse)
-US$5.4M
Median NPV
-US$4.7M
NPV P90 (1 in 10 better)
-US$4.1M
Chance that NPV > 0
< 1 %
Median payback
> 25 yr

Reality check: on 41 operating US farm digesters, reported power output was 0.3–1.6 × this model's estimate for 8 in 10 plants (EPA AgSTAR, self-reported). Until feedstock is weighed and lab-tested, one plant can miss the forecast by that much — more than the range above shows.

What could break the economics

Each stress test applied to the base case on its own.

Change in NPV vs base, USD (base: -4.2M)

  1. CAPEX +20 %-1.3M
  2. Energy prices −20 %-810K
  3. Maintenance +30 %-570K
  4. Feedstock potential −20 %-470K
  5. CH₄ −20 %-330K
  6. CHP downtime +10 pp-200K
  7. Useful heat (economic) −50 %-94K
  8. Feedstock transport +50 %0
NPV = 0 if CAPEX falls by
65 %
grant, leasing, cheaper equipment
NPV = 0 if energy prices rise by
105 %
relative to the base case

Scenarios

Route: CHP (power + heat). Scenarios bundle consistent assumptions (lower yield comes with higher CAPEX).

Revenue + savings / yrUS$440K
  • Electricity self-consumption savings210K
  • Electricity sales150K
  • Incremental digestate value62K
  • Useful heat (economic)18K
OPEX / yrUS$320K
  • Staff120K
  • CHP service and overhaul reserve90K
  • Maintenance79K
  • Insurance27K
Operating margin (EBITDA)US$120K
ScenariosConservativeBaseOptimistic
Biogas, 1 000 Nm³/yr2,001.82,677.73,014.1
CAPEXUS$6.4MUS$5.3MUS$4.8M
OPEX / yrUS$360KUS$320KUS$300K
Revenue + savings / yrUS$300KUS$440KUS$510K
Operating margin (EBITDA)-US$60KUS$120KUS$210K
Simple paybackno payback> 25 yr22.8 yr
Discounted paybackno paybackno paybackno payback
NPV-US$7.2M-US$4.2M-US$2.7M
IRR—-10.8 %-3.9 %
DSCR (min)-0.20.30.5

Pre-tax, nominal USD, 15-year horizon, discount rate of the country or your own; a screening estimate, not a bankable feasibility study. DSCR = EBITDA ÷ debt service at 65 % debt (no taxes).

Cumulative cash flow, USD
-8.2M-6M-3.9M-1.7M460K03691215yearsConservativeBaseOptimistic

Biogas use routes compared

Base case. The model picks the route with the best NPV among technically sensible ones.

RouteCAPEXEBITDA / yrPaybackNPV (base)NPV low…high
CHP (power + heat) chosenUS$5.3MUS$120K> 25 yr-US$4.2M-US$7.2M … -US$2.7M
Boiler (heat only) US$3.5M-US$170Kno payback-US$5.5M-US$7.1M … -US$4.7M
Biomethane US$6.7M-US$140Kno payback-US$8.4M-US$13M … -US$4.6M
  • CHP pays when you use the power yourself and the heat is really used.
  • Biomethane: raw biogas ≈ 274 Nm³/h. The smallest upgrading units take ≈ 50–100 Nm³/h, and the cost per Nm³ falls steeply with size, so a small plant pays much more for each unit of gas.

Plant size

The same feedstock mix at other sizes, each option re-sized by the model. Extra feedstock is assumed on your terms (price, transport, disposal saving); CAPEX is the model's estimate, not your quote.

Sizet/yrBest optionkWeCAPEXNPV (base)
× 0.5 37,000CHP (power + heat)350US$3M-US$2.1M
× 0.75 56,000CHP (power + heat)530US$4.2M-US$3.2M
× 1 your input74,000CHP (power + heat)760US$5.3M-US$4.2M
× 1.5 110,000CHP (power + heat)1,160US$8.9M-US$7.7M
× 2 150,000CHP (power + heat)1,540US$13M-US$12M
× 3 220,000CHP (power + heat)2,320US$22M-US$21M

National support schemes — separate cases

Not in the verdict: tariffs get cut, auctions fail, grant calls close. Status and source shown for each.

Bottom line

Support may be possible, but eligibility is not confirmed

On the scheme's terms the NPV is above zero.

Best option: RFS D3 + California LCFS (manure RNG) Details ↓

NPV change
+US$8.1M
NPV with support
US$3.9M
Payback
6.6 yr
IRR
13.5 %

Next step: Ask the scheme operator in writing whether your project meets the conditions the model does not check.

Country overviewchecked 30 Oct 2026

New RNG used as transport fuel earns federal RFS D3 RINs (realised ≈ $2.45–2.50 in Q2 2026, volatile); manure RNG piped into California can also earn LCFS credits (book-and-claim). The 45Z credit applies to fuel sold by the end of 2029; from 2026 only manure RNG may have a negative carbon intensity (rates for dairy and swine manure are published, beef and poultry pending; IRS Notice 2026-53). It is not included in the support cases. The biogas ITC and REAP digester support are closed.

Open for applications (2)

You can apply now on the published terms.

RFS D3 + California LCFS (manure RNG)

Open
Biomethane support
Eligibility to confirm
Some conditions of this scheme are not checked by the model (see the note): shown "if eligible". Confirm them with the scheme operator.
NPV change
+US$8.1M
NPV with support
US$3.9M
Payback
6.6 yr
IRR
13.5 %
Conditions
  • met: Manure at least 50 % of fresh mass (project 100 %)
  • met: Raw biogas for upgrading from 60 Nm³/h (project ≈ 274 Nm³/h)
Not checked by the model — confirm with the operator:
  • no data: CARB pathway carbon intensity and a transport-fuel contract
What the case uses
  • Route: Biomethane
  • Biomethane price: US$1.16/Nm³
Scheme terms

Gas $3 + 75 % × (D3 $2.00 + LCFS at CI −150 g/MJ, $70/t, 2027 benchmark) ≈ $1.15/Nm³; range $0.81–2.06. Avoided-methane credit for 2 × 10 years if built before 2030.

Next step: Ask the scheme operator in writing whether your project meets the conditions the model does not check.

Source: CARB LCFS regulation (2024 amendments, eff. 2025-07-01) §95484, §95486.1, §95488.9; CARB monthly credit reports Oct 2025 – Sep 2026 ($55–81/t) · checked 30 Oct 2026 · Data confidence: Low

RFS D3 RINs

Open
Biomethane support
Eligibility to confirm
Some conditions of this scheme are not checked by the model (see the note): shown "if eligible". Confirm them with the scheme operator.
NPV change
+US$2.8M
NPV with support
-US$1.4M
Payback
12.8 yr
IRR
3 %
Conditions
  • met: Raw biogas for upgrading from 60 Nm³/h (project ≈ 274 Nm³/h)
Not checked by the model — confirm with the operator:
  • no data: Contracts showing the RNG is used as transport fuel (RFS)
  • no data: D3 RINs only for gas from manure, crop residues, wastewater sludge or landfills; gas from food waste and other non-cellulosic streams earns the lower-priced D5 RIN, and a co-digester splits its RINs by the cellulosic share (RFS)
What the case uses
  • Route: Biomethane
  • Biomethane price: US$0.761/Nm³
Scheme terms

$3/MMBtu gas + 75 % of D3 RINs at a conservative $2.00 (11.73 RIN/MMBtu) ≈ $0.75/Nm³; transport-fuel offtake required.

Next step: Ask the scheme operator in writing whether your project meets the conditions the model does not check.

Source: 40 CFR 80.1415; realised D3 $2.45–2.50/RIN in Q2 2026 (Montauk, OPAL SEC filings); EPA EMTS RIN price data · checked 30 Oct 2026 · Data confidence: Medium

Support never changes the verdict. Each case is pre-tax, uses the scheme's published terms and assumes the support is awarded; it does not confirm eligibility or promise funding.

Where the energy goes

Heat produced ≠ useful heat. Heat without a user isn't income.

42/100

Of every 100 kWh of energy in the methane, 42 become a product that earns money or replaces a purchase.

100 % = 15,000 MWh of methane energy a year (LHV), base case. Every figure in this block is calculated by the model from your inputs.

Stream by stream

Calculated

Earns money

  • Electricity sold to the grid3,300 MWh 23 %
  • Electricity used on site2,100 MWh 14 %
  • Heat for a user640 MWh 4 %

Runs the plant

  • Plant’s own electricity460 MWh 3 %
  • Digester heating2,200 MWh 15 %

Produced, not used

  • Heat with no buyer3,000 MWh 20 %

Losses

  • Conversion losses (engine, boiler)2,400 MWh 16 %
  • Gas sent to the flare280 MWh 2 %
  • Methane leaks220 MWh 1 %

What this means for the project

  • 3,000 MWh of heat a year has no buyer. A heat user nearby (drying, a greenhouse, process heat, a heating network) would turn it into income. At the heat value used in this case that is about US$83K a year.
  • Methane leaks are 1 % of production in the base case: lost income and a greenhouse gas. Gas-tight digestate storage and regular leak checks keep them low.

What the figures rest on

Engine efficiency: electricity / heat
42 % / 45 %Assumption
Heat need
800 MWhYour data
Site electricity use
2,500 MWhYour data
Methane leaks, base case
1 %Assumption
Main product, conservative – optimistic
4,000 – 5,800 MWhCalculated

Season: how much the digester takes for itself

In January heating the digester needs heat equal to 18 % of that month’s methane energy, in July 11 %.

January: methane energy 1,200 MWh · digester heating 220 MWh (18 %) · heat for a user 54 MWh

  • Methane energy of the month
  • Digester heating
  • Heat for a user

How it works: from feedstock to products

  1. Feedstock74,000 t/yr
  2. Biogas2.7M Nm³/yr
  3. Electricity5,500 MWh
  4. Useful heat640 MWh
  5. Heat without demand3,000 MWh
  6. Digestate71,000 t/yr
Heat produced (gross)
5,823 MWh
Digester heat demand
2,193 MWh
Useful heat (economic)
640 MWh of 3,630
Power: own use / sold
2,125 / 3,348 MWh

Climate case (EU RED method)

EU Renewable Energy Directive default values for your feedstock mix, digestate storage and route. Separate from the verdict; outside the EU an indicative benchmark. Credits are valued only in the support cases where an official mechanism exists.

Emissions of the product
-193 g CO₂e/MJ
gas-tight digestate storage
Fossil comparator
183 g CO₂e/MJ
Greenhouse-gas saving
206 %
RED minimum: 80 %
Avoided emissions
7,756 t CO₂e
  • Meets the RED minimum.
  • Below 2 MW rated input the RED criteria do not apply by law; buyers and schemes may still ask for them.
  • Residues other than manure, maize and food waste use the RED biowaste values.

Scores by dimension

No single magic number. The overall score comes with its explanation.

Feedstock fit
89/100
  • Energy equivalent ≈ 760 kWe (scale score 99/100)
  • Feedstock energy ≈ 197 kWh of methane per tonne (score 44/100)
  • Feedstock available 12 of 12 months
Energy fit
52/100
  • Own consumption absorbs 39 % of the electricity produced
  • Useful heat 640 MWh of 3630 MWh available after digester needs
Location & logistics
100/100
  • No critical site constraints found from your answers
Technical feasibility
100/100
  • Standard layout for this scale, no critical obstacles
Economics
0/100
  • Base-case simple payback ≈ 44.3 years
  • Base-case NPV is negative
  • Minimum DSCR 0.28 — below the usual bank threshold of 1.2–1.3
Regulatory complexity
14/100 risk
  • Number and weight of permitting / regulatory steps: 8 points (more = harder)
Environmental risk
24/100 risk
  • Expected methane loss 2.5 % (good practice ≤ 2 %)
Overall project viability
40/100
  • Weighted: economics 30 %, feedstock 20 %, energy 15 %, technical 10 %, location 10 %, regulatory 7.5 %, environment 7.5 %.
  • Capped at 40: weak economics is not offset by other factors.
  • Strongest: Location & logistics (100); weakest: Economics (0).

Calculation details

Feedstock & logistics
Streamt/yrDM, %Nm³ CH₄/tLogistics / energyMax. distance
Dairy cattle slurry61,83012.821.5on site≈ 6 km
Beef / young-stock slurry12,5557.511.4on site≈ 0 km

Max. distance = where haulage eats half of a tonne's energy value. Low-energy feedstock (slurry) belongs next to the plant.

Technology & digester

Wet mesophilic digestion (CSTR)

Vertical CSTR with mechanical mixing and a membrane gas holder

Working volume
≈ 7,100 m³
Retention time
35 days
Loading rate
2.8 kg VS/(m³·d)
Digestate storage
≈ 35,000 m³
  • Dry matter 11.9 %: a liquid mix suited to wet mesophilic digestion.
  • Continuous feed — continuous operation gives steady gas and the simplest control.
  • Mesophilic (≈38 °C): more robust, less heat and complexity. Thermophilic (≈52 °C) only when the benefit outweighs the complexity — rarely at this scale.
  • Two-stage layout (main + post-digester) for stability with fats or larger flows.
Alternatives
  • Horizontal plug-flow as a simpler option for small cattle-manure plants

Climate: Wisconsin (Green Bay), mean 8.8 °C, ≈ 3,662 heating degree-days. Closest climate analogues: Vilnius (LT) (Δ 2.5 °C), Rzeszów (PL) (Δ 2.6 °C), Kraków (PL) (Δ 2.9 °C).

Monthly energy balance

Base case, chosen route. Gas energy is usable methane energy (LHV) after losses.

MonthFeedstock, tGas energy, MWhDigester heat, MWhUseful heat, MWhNet electricity, MWh
Jan6,3131,22822154465
Feb5,7531,11920150423
Mar6,3131,22821654465
Apr6,1101,18819653450
May6,3131,22817254465
Jun6,1101,18814253450
Jul6,3131,22813754465
Aug6,3131,22814354465
Sept6,1101,18815353450
Oct6,3131,22818654465
Nov6,1101,18820853450
Dec6,3131,22821954465
Σ74,38514,4632,1936405,473
CAPEX, OPEX, revenue (base case)
CAPEX (USD)
Digester1.3M
Covering existing storage840K
Feedstock reception and preparation31K
Gas handling and cleaning88K
CHP (power + heat)1.4M
Heat network130K
Backup boiler22K
Electrical systems and controls230K
Pipework150K
Civil works230K
Grid connection82K
Engineering and permits360K
Contingency490K
Total5.3M
OPEX / yr (USD)
Staff120K
CHP service and overhaul reserve90K
Maintenance79K
Insurance27K
Testing and monitoring5.6K
Total320K
Revenue + savings / yr (USD)
Electricity self-consumption savings210K
Electricity sales150K
Useful heat (economic)18K
Incremental digestate value62K
Total440K

Unit costs are estimates. Replace them with supplier quotations.

Digestate: asset or liability

Status: asset · 70,947 t/yr · nitrogen ≈ 396,304 kg/yr · land needed ≈ 2,331 ha (available 2,500 ha).

Incremental fertiliser value US$62K/yr, handling US$0/yr, net US$62K/yr.

  • Digestate storage for 6 months for the closed spreading season; keep ≈ 150 days (incl. the digester) gas-tight, otherwise methane and N are lost.
  • Spread by injection or trailing hose (not splash plate): less odour and ammonia loss.
Methane losses & climate

Expected losses: 2.5 % of methane produced (range 1.6 % – 4 %) ≈ 714 t CO₂e/yr; fossil emissions displaced ≈ 3,002 t CO₂/yr. Losses vs benefit: 24 %.

  • Expected loss 2.5 % is above good practice (2 %): budget for monitoring.
  • Gas-tight covers on the digester and digestate storage (incl. lagoon covers) — the single most important measure.
  • Leak detection and repair (LDAR): optical gas imaging or tracer method at least yearly, plus an acceptance test after construction.
  • Continuous gas-holder pressure monitoring; a standby flare instead of venting.
  • CHP with an oxidation catalyst and tuning regime to cut methane slip.

Avoided emissions from open manure storage are not credited (conservative).

Permits & regulation (indicative)

Complexity: lower. “To verify” means a local lawyer or engineer must confirm the item during the feasibility study.

  • State air permit (CHP/flare) and possibly Title V; EPA NSPS/NESHAP for engines
    Combustion of biogas · effort: medium · to verify
  • CAFO / NPDES and state nutrient-management plan for digestate
    Manure / digestate land application · effort: medium · to verify
  • County zoning / conditional-use permit and building permits
    New installation · effort: medium · to verify
  • Utility interconnection agreement (state rules / FERC for wholesale)
    Electricity export · effort: medium · to verify
Safety (risk register)
  • Methane: explosion and fire (flammable range ≈ 5–15 % in air) high
    • Hazardous-area (ATEX/IECEx or national) zoning and suitably rated equipment
    • Fixed gas detectors in the CHP room and near tanks
    • Flame arresters, over/under-pressure relief, safety flare
    • Ignition-source control and hot-work permits
  • Hydrogen sulphide (H₂S): acute toxicity, corrosion high
    • Biological / chemical desulphurisation of the biogas
    • Personal H₂S monitors, no lone working
    • H₂S monitoring upstream of the CHP (engine protection)
  • Confined spaces (digester, storage, pits): asphyxiation, toxic gases high
    • Entry only under permit, ventilation, standby person
    • Self-contained breathing apparatus for rescue
  • Over/under-pressure: membrane roof rupture, tank deformation medium
    • Liquid seals / relief valves venting to a safe location
    • Gas-holder level and pressure sensors
  • CHP: carbon monoxide, fire, high temperatures medium
    • CHP room ventilation, CO detectors
    • Emergency stop, fire suppression
  • Soil and water pollution: slurry/digestate spills, lagoon overflow high
    • Bund sized for the largest tank
    • Level sensors and a spill-response plan
    • Digestate storage covering the closed spreading season

Software does NOT replace a qualified process engineer and a process-safety engineer. Every final engineering design, hazardous-area classification and safe-operation programme must pass human professional review.

Assumptions used (146)

Every number has a source, date, country and confidence, and is tagged FACT / ASSUMPTION / CALCULATION / ESTIMATE. Full register: →

  • Support: New RNG used as transport fuel earns federal RFS D3 RINs (realised ≈ $2.45–2.50 in Q2 2026, volatile); manure RNG piped into California can also earn LCFS credits (book-and-claim). The 45Z credit applies to fuel sold by the end of 2029; from 2026 only manure RNG may have a negative carbon intensity (rates for dairy and swine manure are published, beef and poultry pending; IRS Notice 2026-53). It is not included in the support cases. The biogas ITC and REAP digester support are closed.
  • Low gas prices make biogas without credits unattractive; transport-fuel credits, not electricity savings, decide most US projects.
  • The verdict excludes subsidies; national support is shown as separate cases.
  • This is a preliminary (screening) assessment — not a detailed engineering design and not a commercial offer.
  • Financial results are pre-tax project cash flows. Depreciation, income taxes, working capital, financing fees and detailed debt covenants are not modelled; DSCR is an EBITDA-based screening ratio, not lender CFADS.
  • Parameter bounds are tested individually using the applicable market/CAPEX evidence. These engineering or tariff ranges are not statistical confidence intervals and do not replace supplier quotations or customer bills.

What could break the economics

Each stress test applied to the base case on its own.

chp: local CAPEX factor
0.784 … 1.456 —
NPV low…high: -US$6.2M … -US$2.3M
Discount rate (nominal, pre-tax, EUR-equivalent, incl. country risk)
0.051 … 0.081 —
NPV low…high: -US$4.4M … -US$4.1M
Business electricity reference, excl. VAT (default if the customer gives none)
0.096 … 0.1373 USD/kWh
NPV low…high: -US$4.7M … -US$3.8M
Mineral potassium price
0.7981 … 0.9065 USD/kg K₂O
NPV low…high: -US$4.2M … -US$4.2M
Mineral nitrogen price
1.17 … 2.035 USD/kg N
NPV low…high: -US$4.4M … -US$4M
Mineral phosphorus price
1.588 … 2.068 USD/kg P₂O₅
NPV low…high: -US$4.2M … -US$4.2M
Share of the bill actually avoided by self-generation
0.7 … 1 —
NPV low…high: -US$4.6M … -US$3.8M
Every number has a source, date, country and confidence, and is tagged FACT / ASSUMPTION / CALCULATION / ESTIMATE. Full register:
Biomethane price without support, base: 0.2239 USD/Nm³ · CALCULATED_VALUE · LOW
National estimate (project team, 2026-10) — no official series found for this item; your own price overrides it; local market for biomethane / RNG without credits
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 400-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
chp: local CAPEX factor: 1.12 — · CALCULATED_VALUE · LOW
chp only. Labour formula gives 0.97, but US EPA AgSTAR cost data ($1 100–1 500 per cow at 500 cows) sit ≈ 15–25 % above the model at factor 1.0: higher engineering, permitting and interconnection cost
ASSUMPTION: Engineering estimate or reconstructed cost; a recent review date does not establish current market validity
Debt interest rate (EUR-equivalent): 0.046 — · CALCULATED_VALUE · MEDIUM
Discount rate − 1.5 pp (senior debt is cheaper than blended project capital); consistent with ECB MIR corporate loan rates + project margin; a bank term sheet replaces this
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 400-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
Debt share for DSCR test: 0.65 — · ENGINEERING_ASSUMPTION · MEDIUM
Typical agri / project lending (KfW, EBRD, IFC practice)
ASSUMPTION: Engineering estimate or reconstructed cost; a recent review date does not establish current market validity
Debt tenor: 10 a · ENGINEERING_ASSUMPTION · MEDIUM
Typical
ASSUMPTION: Engineering estimate or reconstructed cost; a recent review date does not establish current market validity
Digestate that has no adequate land: 12.48 USD/t · CALCULATED_VALUE · MEDIUM
Third-party export of digestate ≈ 2.5 €/t + 0.22 h/t × labour; ≈ 12 €/t in Germany, in line with manure-exchange prices in surplus regions (LWK Niedersachsen Nährstoffbericht: 10–20 €/t)
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 400-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
Incremental digestate handling on adequate land: 4.858 USD/t · CALCULATED_VALUE · MEDIUM
Pumping & trailing-hose spreading ≈ 1.2 €/t machinery + 0.08 h/t × labour; ≈ 4.8 €/t in Germany, in line with KTBL contractor rates (3–6 €/m³)
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 400-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
Discount rate (nominal, pre-tax, EUR-equivalent, incl. country risk): 0.061 — · CALCULATED_VALUE · MEDIUM
Nominal, pre-tax, EUR-equivalent: 6.0 % mature-market WACC + 0.6 × country risk premium 0.22 % (Aa1; Damodaran, 2026-07); not a bank offer
2026-07-01 · checked 2026-10-27 · Rating-based CRP; baseline WACC and lambda are engineering/financial assumptions
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 400-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
Business electricity reference, excl. VAT (default if the customer gives none): 0.1167 USD/kWh · CALCULATED_VALUE · MEDIUM
EIA Electric Power Monthly 5.6.B, Wisconsin, 2026-01/2026-08: commercial 13.73 ¢, industrial 9.60 ¢/kWh → midpoint for farms and food processors, excl. taxes; converted at 1.1193 USD/EUR
2026-01/2026-08 · checked 2026-10-31 · Wisconsin; sector averages, not the customer's tariff
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 400-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
Wholesale electricity price (market average): 0.05264 USD/kWh · CALCULATED_VALUE · MEDIUM
EIA STEO table 7a: Midcontinent ISO Illinois hub, 2025-10 – 2026-09 mean $52.64/MWh (hub serving Wisconsin); converted at 1.1193 USD/EUR
2025-10-01 / 2026-09-30 · checked 2026-10-31 · Wholesale hub assigned to Wisconsin; not a guaranteed export price
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 60-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
Annual escalation of energy prices (nominal EUR): 0.02 — · ENGINEERING_ASSUMPTION · MEDIUM
At the ECB/Fed inflation target — no real energy-price growth assumed (conservative)
ASSUMPTION: Engineering estimate or reconstructed cost; a recent review date does not establish current market validity
Share of the wholesale price realised for surplus power: 0.85 — · ENGINEERING_ASSUMPTION · MEDIUM
15 % profile & balancing discount for a small seller (assumption, same for all markets)
ASSUMPTION: Engineering estimate or reconstructed cost; a recent review date does not establish current market validity
Mineral potassium price: 0.8519 USD/kg K₂O · CALCULATED_VALUE · MEDIUM
World Bank Pink Sheet, 12-month mean 2025M10–2026M09; ÷ nutrient share × 1.35 farm-gate markup
2025M10 / 2026M09 · checked 2026-10-27 · World commodity reference; actual digestate nutrient substitution and local fertiliser price require confirmation
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 400-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
Trailing-year commodity reference: 378.6 USD/t product (MARKET_DATA); Latest-month reference (2026-09): 367.5 USD/t product (MARKET_DATA); FX (2026-11-09): 1.119 USD/EUR (MARKET_DATA); Farm-gate markup: 1.35 — (ENGINEERING_ASSUMPTION)
Mineral nitrogen price: 1.489 USD/kg N · CALCULATED_VALUE · MEDIUM
World Bank Pink Sheet, 12-month mean 2025M10–2026M09; ÷ nutrient share × 1.35 farm-gate markup
2025M10 / 2026M09 · checked 2026-10-27 · World commodity reference; actual digestate nutrient substitution and local fertiliser price require confirmation
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 400-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
Trailing-year commodity reference: 507.3 USD/t product (MARKET_DATA); Latest-month reference (2026-09): 407.5 USD/t product (MARKET_DATA); FX (2026-11-09): 1.119 USD/EUR (MARKET_DATA); Farm-gate markup: 1.35 — (ENGINEERING_ASSUMPTION)
Mineral phosphorus price: 1.878 USD/kg P₂O₅ · CALCULATED_VALUE · MEDIUM
World Bank Pink Sheet, 12-month mean 2025M10–2026M09; ÷ nutrient share × 1.35 farm-gate markup
2025M10 / 2026M09 · checked 2026-10-27 · World commodity reference; actual digestate nutrient substitution and local fertiliser price require confirmation
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 400-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
Trailing-year commodity reference: 639.8 USD/t product (MARKET_DATA); Latest-month reference (2026-09): 690 USD/t product (MARKET_DATA); FX (2026-11-09): 1.119 USD/EUR (MARKET_DATA); Farm-gate markup: 1.35 — (ENGINEERING_ASSUMPTION)
Exchange rate: 1.119 USD/EUR · MARKET_DATA · HIGH
Official EUR reference rate, 2026-11-09
2026-11-09 · checked 2026-11-10 · USD per EUR; dated reference, not a guaranteed transaction rate
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 7-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
Value of useful heat (displaced gas / boiler efficiency): 0.02768 USD/kWh th · CALCULATED_VALUE · MEDIUM
Business gas 22.257518091664434 €/MWh LHV ÷ 0.9
2025-09 / 2026-08 · checked 2026-10-31 · Wisconsin
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 400-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
Evaluation horizon: 15 a · ENGINEERING_ASSUMPTION · MEDIUM
Shorter than the 20-year technical life — conservative
ASSUMPTION: Engineering estimate or reconstructed cost; a recent review date does not establish current market validity
Official hourly labour cost, economy-wide (wages + employer costs): 46.89 USD/h · CALCULATED_VALUE · HIGH
BLS Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, private industry, 2026-Q02: $46.89 per hour worked; converted at 1.1193 USD/EUR
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 730-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
Plant operator wage relative to the economy-wide average: 0.9385 — · CALCULATED_VALUE · MEDIUM
BLS OEWS May 2025, water & wastewater treatment plant operators, Wisconsin: mean $30.8/h ÷ ECEC private-industry wages $32.82/h (2026-Q02)
May 2025 · checked 2026-10-31 · Wisconsin
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 730-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
Annual escalation of operating costs (nominal EUR): 0.025 — · ENGINEERING_ASSUMPTION · MEDIUM
Inflation target + 0.5 pp wage drift
ASSUMPTION: Engineering estimate or reconstructed cost; a recent review date does not establish current market validity
Share of the bill actually avoided by self-generation: 0.85 — · ENGINEERING_ASSUMPTION · MEDIUM
TOU reference: energy/Ft portion only, demand/service charges retained. Else 85% engineering allowance. User invoice uses the generic allowance until its energy/demand split is known.
ASSUMPTION: Engineering estimate or reconstructed cost; a recent review date does not establish current market validity
Road transport of organic feedstock: 0.1992 USD/(t·km) · CALCULATED_VALUE · MEDIUM
0.06 €/t·km vehicle & fuel + 0.003 × driver labour cost (€/h); matches KTBL slurry haulage ≈ 0.12–0.16 €/t·km in Germany
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 400-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked
Loading/unloading per tonne: 1.556 USD/t · CALCULATED_VALUE · MEDIUM
0.6 €/t pump & loader + 0.02 h/t × labour cost (KTBL Betriebsplanung machine-cost norms, scaled by national labour cost)
WITHIN_REVIEW_WINDOW: Within the 400-day review policy; applicability and latest publication must still be checked