The sludge is dilute and the quantity is small compared with the cost of a digester. In our model the Swedish RAS case shows weak economics. Biogas becomes sensible only when sludge is added to a larger plant nearby, or when the farm is big.
What drives payback
The more water, the less gas per tonne. Thickening before digestion changes the economics.
A farm produces small tonnage. Fixed cost of the plant weighs heavily on it.
Phosphorus and nitrogen in the sludge are useful on land and may be worth more than the gas.
Delivering the sludge to an existing digester avoids a new investment.
What it takes to work
- Sludge thickened before digestion
- A nearby digester that accepts the sludge
- A local use for the digestate and its nutrients
Frequently asked questions
Is biogas ever worthwhile for a fish farm?
For a very large farm or as a supplier to a nearby plant. For a small farm usually not.
What are the alternatives?
Composting, drying and use as fertiliser, or delivery to a municipal plant.
Can I add other waste?
Yes, if it is available near the farm; then the calculation is for the mix.